Music Library Staff Guide: Collection Development Assistance

Collection Development

"Collection development is the thoughtful process of developing a library collection in response to institutional priorities and community or user needs and interests"

Johnson, Peggy. Fundamentals of Collection Development and Management. 2nd ed. London: Facet, 2014.

Collection Development Forms

Please note that some of these forms are still in development; Holling may ask that you use paper bookmarks instead.  Always check with Holling first.

Romans Gift, not art/classical musicRomans Gift, art/classical musicWise Gift Grooved Media (45s, 78s, Vinyl, Shellac) General FormArt Music, General (in development)

"Cat'-Checking" : Collecting information/statistics to aid in collection development decisions

This is the time hone your searching skills! It’s tremendously ineffective to browse through a long list of results when looking for a specific item. Use the techniques you have learned to create searches that are specific enough to retrieve a small/manageable list of results. Remember that, in Library Catalog, you can include the editor and publisher. In WorldCat, publisher searches must go in the publisher search box. Use the advance search to limit your scope or look for helpful keywords to add to your arsenal of search terms, such as “ Vocal score[s]”, “parts”, “scores”, “disc[s]” (for CDs and LPs), “videodisc[s]” (for DVDs), etc.  Feel free to pose questions to full-time staff!

You’ll be looking for “true duplicates” of each item. The term “true duplicate” means, in addition to a matching author and title, the edition (1st, 2nd, etc.), publisher, date of publication, and format (score, score & parts, or parts) should be identical as well in order for the item to be a true duplicate. 

Cat'-Checking Procedures

  • When cat-checking a list of items, you’ll be looking for “true duplicates” of each item.  The term “true duplicate” means, in addition to a matching author and title, the edition (1st, 2nd, etc.), publisher, date of publication, and format (score, score & parts, or parts) should be identical as well in order for the item to be a true duplicate. 
  • When you’ve found a true duplicate of an item in Library Catalog, write an “X” next to that item. 
  • When you’ve found a similar item, but not a true duplicate, write “LH” (Library Has) and succinctly include how the item differs from the item on the list.  Exs. LH 2nd ed., LH 2008 Henle [Henle is the publisher], LH 2009 Naxos recording by Bournemouth S[ymphony]O[rchestra]. 
  • When we don’t have any copies of the item, write a “0” (zero) next to the item.
  • You may also be asked to include WorldCat holdings for each item. After finding the item in WorldCat, the number of holdings will be next to “Libraries Worldwide” or “Libraries Worldwide that own item”. Record holdings next to the item as “WC: [number]”.
  • In WorldCat, you may sometimes find more than one record for the same item.  When this happens, add up the holding's numbers for each record and notate next to total recorded holdings next to each item on the list.

Cat'-Checking With Supplied Paper Bookmarks

  • Library Catalog: Y  N  - If you’ve found a true duplicate of an item in Library Catalog, circle "Y". If not, circle "N".  If you’ve found a similar item, but not a true duplicate, write “LH” (Library Has) and concisely include how the item differs from the item on the list. Exs. LH 2nd ed., LH 2008 Henle [Henle is the publisher], LH 2009 Naxos recording by Bournemouth S[ymphony]O[rchestra]. 
  • If cop. 2, circ = -  If Library Catalog: Y  N, is marked "N", skip this. If a true duplicate is found in Library Catalog, we'll want to know how many times our copy or copies have checked out.  Search for the title and once you find the exact duplicate that we own, expand the item record and click on other details. Total together the number of loans and number of in house uses and document on the bookmark.
  • For WC:, you've been asked to include WorldCat holdings for the item. After finding the true duplicate in WorldCat, the number of holdings will be next to "Holding Libraries" in the new version of WorldCat or next to “Libraries Worldwide” or “Libraries Worldwide that own item” in the old version of WorldCat. Record the number of holdings next to “WC:”. In WorldCat, you may sometimes find more than one record for the same item. When this happens, add the number of holdings for each record, feeling free to round up.
  • Add your initials.
  • Disregard DECISION and what follows.