GSS 2246: Banned Books

What is the difference between scholarly & popular sources?

GSS Librarian

Profile Photo
Brenna Bierman
she/her
Contact:
Central Library - 800FH
615-343-2718

What is a Scholarly Source?

For your assignment, you need to find scholarly sources. It is easiest to find scholarly sources by searching the library website, or using an academic database, which are outlined in the "Searching for Sources" page. Once you've found a few sources you would like to use for your assignment, you can go through the following table to help determine whether or not your source is scholarly. 

Criteria Popular   Scholarly

Length of articles

Broad range of topics, presented in shorter articles

 

Specific, often narrowly focused topics in lengthy, in-depth articles

Audience

Intended to attract a general readership without any particular expertise or advanced education

 

Intended for specialist readership of researchers, academics, students, and professionals

Authority/Expertise

Written by journalists, staff, or freelance writers using popular language

 

Written by specialists and researchers in subject area, usually employing technical, subject-specific language and jargon

Format/Bibliography

Articles rarely contain references or footnotes and follow no specific format

 

Well-researched, documented articles nearly always follow standard format: abstract, introduction, literature review, methodology, results, conclusion, bibliography/references

Frequency

Published frequently (i.e., weekly, biweekly, or monthly)

 

Usually monthly, quarterly, or once or twice per year

Inclusions

Designed to attract eye of potential newsstand customers: usually filled with photographs or illustrations

 

Sober design: mostly text with some tables or graphs accompanying articles; usually little or no photography; negligible, if any, advertising

Pagination

Each issue begins with page number '1'

 

Page numbers of issues within a volume (year) are usually consecutive (i.e., first page of succeeding issue is number following last page number of previous issue)

Purpose

Presented to entertain, promote point of view, and/or sell products

 

Intended to present researchers' findings and conclusions based on original research

Adapted from University of California Santa Cruz. https://guides.library.ucsc.edu/distinguish-between-popular-and-scholarly-journals

What is peer review?